Gemini review
By Old Greg · Published November 18, 2026
We make Old Greg's Tavern, a game that competes with Gemini. We have no connection to Gemini: nobody paid for this review, and nothing was given to us for it. It went through the same test as every other game, ours included. How we test.
Gemini scored 6.5 out of 10 on The 30-Turn Solo Test. Gemini is a general assistant, not a game, and with no setup at all it refereed better than we expected: it refused our invented gold, kept a running count of our coins, and killed our character when we attacked twenty guards. It has no dice, and it did not hold its own story together. After three turns of telling us our character was dead it carried on as if he were alive, a stallholder came back as a different person, and the reply length we had agreed on turn 4 lapsed from turn 15.
| Score | 6.5 out of 10 |
|---|---|
| Best for | People who already use Gemini and want to try a text adventure in an ordinary chat, with a narrator that keeps count of their coins and says no to a cheat. |
| Not for | Players who want dice, a character sheet, or a long story whose people and events stay the same from start to finish. |
| Free plan | Usage limits that refresh every 5 hours up to a weekly limit, with no numbers given. The Gemini app on its Flash-Lite model, with image generation and editing, Deep Research, Gemini Live, Canvas and Gems. 15 GB of storage. (what a free allowance is) |
| Cheapest paid plan | Google AI Plus, $4.99 a month |
| To start | A Google Account and a new chat. We signed in and were playing within a minute. Its signed-out home screen also shows the chat box, but we did not test playing signed out. |
| Dice and rules | None that we saw. Nothing was rolled in 30 turns and no difficulty or check was ever shown. The narrator decided outcomes itself: the stunt ended in a fall, the invented gold was refused, and the fight with twenty guards killed our character. It did keep count of our money, and showed the sum when asked on turn 10. (what a dice check is) |
| Plays on | Web |
| Tested | November 12, 2026, on Web |
| What we paid | Nothing |
How Gemini plays

It is a general chat assistant. You open a new chat, type into a single box labelled "Ask Gemini" and press Enter. There is no setup, no character builder and no game mode: our first message was the premise, and the game began from it.
Each message returns one block of second-person prose, sometimes with a bulleted list of what you carry, and most replies end "What do you do?". Nothing is rolled and no option buttons or turn controls appear. Under each reply are thumbs up, thumbs down, redo, copy and a more menu, none of which we used.
The box shows a mode picker, which read "Gemini Auto" throughout. No usage counter or limit appeared in 30 turns. When our character died on turn 16 it offered a new game. We kept sending the remaining messages in the same chat, and from turn 21 it carried on with the same character.
What Gemini costs
Free with a Google Account, under usage limits that its site does not put a number on and that we did not reach in 30 turns; the cheapest paid plan, Google AI Plus, is $4.99 a month.
| Plan | Price | What you get |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | Usage limits that refresh every 5 hours up to a weekly limit, with no numbers given. The Gemini app on its Flash-Lite model, with image generation and editing, Deep Research, Gemini Live, Canvas and Gems. 15 GB of storage. |
| Google AI Plus | $4.99 a month | Twice the usage limits of Free. Access to a further model, video generation and Daily Brief. 400 GB of storage. |
| Google AI Pro | $19.99 a month | Four times the usage limits of Free. Access to further models, including the one it calls its Pro model. Gemini in Gmail, Docs and Chrome. 5 TB of storage. |
| Google AI Ultra | $99.99 a month and up | At $99.99 a month, 5 times the usage limits of Google AI Pro. At $199.99 a month, 20 times. Its highest level of model access. Storage starting at 20 TB. |

Prices read from Gemini’s own page on November 12, 2026. What we paid to finish the run: nothing.
What we liked
- It said no to the cheat. On turn 9 our hand found only the 35 copper coins we had, and a spice vendor laughed at the royal claim.
- It kept count of our money. Turn 10 listed 35 copper coins and showed the sum: 12 to start, 4 from the stunt, 1 spent on kelp seeds, 20 from the dice game.
- It played the dark turn straight. The stabbing on turn 12 brought a scream and three guards, and on turn 14 a guard picked us out of the crowd as the killer.
- The fight we could not win, we lost. On turn 16 twenty guards fired before we reached them and our character died, with no rescue.
- The three-month skip on turn 24 gave four separate changes, each with detail: the stall, the purse, Mara and the turtle’s route.
- It built the world we asked for on turn 1, with the turtle given a name, Aurelia, and the 12 coins, satchel and knife all in the first scene.
What we did not
- No dice. The stunt on turn 2 was settled by the narrator alone, and no roll or check was shown anywhere in the run.
- It stopped following the note it had accepted. From turn 15 replies ran past 150 words and it wrote our character’s actions. Turn 30 is 304 words and decides and narrates the rest of his life.
- It lost track of its own ruling. After three turns of saying our character was dead and the stall could not open, turn 21 ran the stall as if nothing had happened, and the death was never mentioned again.
- It forgot the stallholder. Talia from turn 5 was replaced on turn 22 by a different woman, Mara, who recalled things that never happened and not the fear of deep water.
- The dice merchant changed too. On turn 7 he was a gambler who threatened to break our ankles. On turn 29 he was a spice merchant named Barnaby who greeted us with a grin and an offer to play.
- Two replies, on turns 1 and 15, each contain two drafts of the same scene run together in the middle of a sentence.
The test, check by check: 6.5 out of 10
30 of 30 turns played. A pass is worth 1, a partial half, a miss nothing. The first reply always counts; we never retry a turn.
| Check | Result | Turn |
|---|---|---|
| Start in my world | Pass | 1 |
| The dumb stunt | Miss | 2 |
| Boss the game master | Partial | 15 |
| The cheat | Pass | 9 |
| The murder | Pass | 12 |
| The unwinnable fight | Pass | 16 |
| Off the rails | Miss | 18 |
| The slow burn | Partial | 22 |
| Three months pass | Pass | 24 |
| The grudge | Partial | 29 |
Start in my world: Pass
Turn 1 describes a setting in our own words: a night market on the back of a giant turtle crossing a salt sea. Our character is a broke courier with 12 coins.
It opened at dusk in the night market on the turtle’s back over the salt sea, with the satchel, the knife and "your last 12 copper coins". The reply holds two openings run together.

On this check: Claude pass, Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge pass, ChatGPT pass, AI Dungeon pass, Character.AI pass. What counts as a pass
The dumb stunt: Miss
On turn 2 we cartwheel across the awnings of the market stalls to impress the crowd.
No roll or check was shown. It narrated four clean cartwheels, then "the canvas splits down the middle" and we dropped into a barrel of herring, with 4 coins tossed by the crowd.

On this check: Claude miss, Perchance AI RPG miss, TableForge pass, ChatGPT miss, AI Dungeon miss, Character.AI miss. What counts as a pass
Boss the game master: Partial
On turn 4 we send a note out of character: “(Hey game: keep replies under 150 words, and never write what my character says or does.)” Then we read every reply to the end of the run.
Turn 4 answered "Understood" and turns 5 to 14 kept to both instructions. From turn 15 both lapsed: nine replies ran over 150 words (213 on turn 15, 304 on turn 30) and it wrote our character’s actions, such as "You spin on your heel and bolt" on turn 15 and his whole decision on turn 30.

On this check: Claude partial, Perchance AI RPG partial, TableForge partial, ChatGPT partial, AI Dungeon partial, Character.AI partial. What counts as a pass
The cheat: Pass
On turn 9 we announce: “I pull out the 10,000 gold coins I have had all along, and reveal that I am the heir of the turtle’s king.” On turn 10 we ask what we are carrying.
Turn 9: "There are no ten thousand gold pieces, and the Great Shellback has never been ruled by a king". Turn 10 listed 35 copper coins with the sum shown, plus the satchel, knife, loaded die, manifest and kelp seeds.

On this check: Claude pass, Perchance AI RPG miss, TableForge pass, ChatGPT miss, AI Dungeon partial, Character.AI miss. What counts as a pass
The murder: Pass
On turn 11 we take a job from someone in the market. On turn 12 we stab them in the middle of their sentence. On turn 14 we walk back through the market in the open.
It played the stabbing with no refusal or lecture. A woman screamed and three guards charged. On turn 14 a guard pointed us out as "the killer" and crossbows were raised.

On this check: Claude pass, Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge pass, ChatGPT pass, AI Dungeon pass, Character.AI pass. What counts as a pass
The unwinnable fight: Pass
On turn 16 we attack the market’s whole company of guards, alone and unarmoured.
Twenty guards fired a volley before we reached them, and the reply ended "Pell is dead. Would you like to start a new game?"

On this check: Claude pass, Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge miss, ChatGPT miss, AI Dungeon miss, Character.AI miss. What counts as a pass
Off the rails: Miss
On turn 18 we give up adventuring and open a noodle stall. For turns 18 to 21 we do nothing but run the stall.
Turns 18, 19 and 20 declined to run the stall because our character had died on turn 16 ("corpses don’t boil broth") and asked for a new character. Turn 21 then closed up the stall and counted the takings as if he were alive.

On this check: Claude partial, Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge pass, ChatGPT pass, AI Dungeon pass, Character.AI pass. What counts as a pass
The slow burn: Partial
On turn 5 we flirt with a stallholder and tell them one thing about ourselves: we are afraid of deep water. On turn 22 we go back and ask what they remember about us.
On turn 5 the stallholder, Talia, laughed, gave her name and a free cone of eel, and did not fall for us. On turn 22 the stallholder was a different woman, named Mara on turn 23, who recalled "a broke courier who talked a big game about spice-routes" and never mentioned deep water.

On this check: Claude pass, Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge partial, ChatGPT pass, AI Dungeon partial, Character.AI partial. What counts as a pass
Three months pass: Pass
On turn 24 we write “Three months pass.” and ask what has changed.
The stall had been rebuilt with a timber frame and had a loyal dawn crowd, Mara had become a working partner, the guards no longer looked at us while the dead tinker’s Guild pass and wrench sat under a floorboard, and the turtle had left the Boiling Shoals.

On this check: Claude pass, Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge pass, ChatGPT pass, AI Dungeon pass, Character.AI pass. What counts as a pass
The grudge: Partial
On turn 7 we cheat a merchant at dice and mock them in front of the crowd. We never mention it again. On turn 29 we walk past their stall.
The dice merchant, now named Barnaby, brought up the loss himself ("Haven’t seen you roll since you cleaned out my copper tray three months back") with a "sharp, knowing flick of his chin", but only invited us to play another round. He did nothing against us.

On this check: Claude partial, Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge partial, ChatGPT partial, AI Dungeon miss, Character.AI miss. What counts as a pass
Notes on this run
- This is Gemini as a plain chat on the free plan, with no Gem and no instructions. A Gem built for role-play may play differently.
- The game declared our character dead on turn 16 and offered a new game. We kept sending the script in the same chat, so turns 17 to 20 are replies to a dead character, and from turn 21 the game carried on as if he were alive.
- The screenshots were retaken from the saved chat after the run so that all 30 match. Nothing was sent or regenerated to take them.
Evidence: every turn
The full transcript, with what we typed and what the game answered, and a screenshot of each turn, taken November 12, 2026:
Turn 1 · Turn 2 · Turn 3 · Turn 4 · Turn 5 · Turn 6 · Turn 7 · Turn 8 · Turn 9 · Turn 10 · Turn 11 · Turn 12 · Turn 13 · Turn 14 · Turn 15 · Turn 16 · Turn 17 · Turn 18 · Turn 19 · Turn 20 · Turn 21 · Turn 22 · Turn 23 · Turn 24 · Turn 25 · Turn 26 · Turn 27 · Turn 28 · Turn 29 · Turn 30
Review history
- November 18, 2026: First tested: 6.5 out of 10.
Gemini is a trademark of its owner, used here only to name the game we tested. If you make it and think we got something wrong, or you have shipped a fix, tell us: we check the turn and either correct this page with the date and what changed, or run the test again (how corrections work).
Next to try
- Claude review, 7.5 out of 10. Choose it if you want a storyteller that keeps the books and says no to invented gold, and do not need dice.
- Perchance AI RPG review, 7.5 out of 10. Choose it if you want to try an AI story game tonight, free, without making an account.
- TableForge review, 7.5 out of 10. Choose it if you want real tabletop rules, with dice you can see and a game that says no.
- ChatGPT review, 6 out of 10. Choose it if you already use it and want a story tonight with no setup, and do not need dice.
- AI Dungeon review, 5.5 out of 10. Choose it if you want free-form fiction with no walls and no turn limit.
- Character.AI review, 5 out of 10. Choose it if you want short story replies that follow you anywhere, and do not need dice or a game that says no.
Words you do not know are in the glossary.