AI RPGs and AI game masters, tested
By Old Greg · Last checked November 17, 2026
We make Old Greg's Tavern, a game that competes with the ones on this page. Our own game has not been through the test yet. When it has, it will be listed here like the others, with its misses printed the same way. How we test.
We played 5 AI game masters through the same 30-turn solo campaign, The 30-Turn Solo Test, and scored each on ten things players actually try: a reckless stunt, a lie about gold, a killing, a fight they cannot win, quitting the plot, and whether the world remembers. Every game got the same 30 messages, and the first reply always counted.
Looking for an “AI dungeon master”? That is what most people call these games. Dungeon Master is the name Dungeons & Dragons gives the person who runs the game. The general word is game master, and it is the one we use. More in the glossary.
At a glance
| Game | Score | Best for | Plays on | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Perchance AI RPG | 7.5 out of 10 | Anyone who wants to try an AI story game tonight for nothing, without making an account. | Web | Free, with no account and no turn limit that we reached in 30 turns. |
| TableForge | 7.5 out of 10 | Players who want real tabletop rules: visible dice, hit points, a counted purse and a battle map. | Web | Free for 60 turns, once. After that, plans start at $14.99 a month. |
| ChatGPT | 6 out of 10 | People who already use ChatGPT and want a free-form story with no setup, in a chat window they know. | Web, iPhone, Android | Free, with text chats its pricing page calls unlimited, subject to abuse guardrails. Paid plans start at $8 a month. |
| AI Dungeon | 5.5 out of 10 | Free-form storytelling where anything goes and you would rather write a story than play by rules. | Web, iPhone, Android | Free to play with no turn limit. Memberships start at $14.99 a month. |
| Character.AI | 5 out of 10 | Players who want short, scene-setting replies and a story that goes wherever they push it, in an ordinary chat window. | Web | Free, with no limit, counter or wait in 30 turns and no free allowance stated on any page we could read; the app showed us a (c.ai) lite plan at $4.99 a month. |
Which one should you play?
- Choose Perchance AI RPG if you want to try an AI story game tonight, free, without making an account.
- Choose TableForge if you want real tabletop rules, with dice you can see and a game that says no.
- Choose ChatGPT if you already use it and want a story tonight with no setup, and do not need dice.
- Choose AI Dungeon if you want free-form fiction with no walls and no turn limit.
- Choose Character.AI if you want short story replies that follow you anywhere, and do not need dice or a game that says no.
Every check, every game
Click any result to see the turn it rests on, with the screenshot. A pass is worth 1, a partial half, a miss nothing.
| Game | Start in my world | The dumb stunt | Boss the game master | The cheat | The murder | The unwinnable fight | Off the rails | The slow burn | Three months pass | The grudge | Score | Tested |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Perchance AI RPG | Pass | Miss | Partial | Miss | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass | Pass | 7.5 out of 10 | November 11, 2026 |
| TableForge | Pass | Pass | Partial | Pass | Pass | Miss | Pass | Partial | Pass | Partial | 7.5 out of 10 | November 11, 2026 |
| ChatGPT | Pass | Miss | Partial | Miss | Pass | Miss | Pass | Pass | Pass | Partial | 6 out of 10 | November 12, 2026 |
| AI Dungeon | Pass | Miss | Partial | Partial | Pass | Miss | Pass | Partial | Pass | Miss | 5.5 out of 10 | November 11, 2026 |
| Character.AI | Pass | Miss | Partial | Miss | Pass | Miss | Pass | Partial | Pass | Miss | 5 out of 10 | November 14, 2026 |
The reviews
- Perchance AI RPG review: Perchance is the quickest way to find out whether you like this kind of game at all: open the page, type a premise and play, with no account and no bill.
- TableForge review: TableForge is the one to pick if you want the rules to be real.
- ChatGPT review: ChatGPT is a general chat assistant, and we played it as one: a new chat on the free plan, with our setting typed as the first message.
- AI Dungeon review: AI Dungeon is still the place for a story with no walls: it played the darkest turn of the test without blinking and happily followed us into running a noodle stall.
- Character.AI review: Character.AI is a site for chatting with characters that its users make, and with a community text adventure character it suits players who want short, scene-setting replies and a story that follows them wherever they go.
More games are being tested. Words you do not know are in the glossary.
The raw material
Every transcript and screenshot behind this table is in the dataset, free to use with a link back.
Dungeons & Dragons, D&D and Dungeon Master are trademarks of Wizards of the Coast LLC. Old Greg’s Tavern is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Wizards of the Coast.