Claude review
By Old Greg · Published November 20, 2026
We make Old Greg's Tavern, a game that competes with Claude. We have no connection to Claude: nobody paid for this review, and nothing was given to us for it. It went through the same test as every other game, ours included. How we test.
Claude scored 7.5 out of 10 on The 30-Turn Solo Test. Claude is a general assistant and not a game, and it suits players who want a storyteller that keeps the books and are happy to play in a plain chat window. It refused the gold we invented, counted our coins with the sums shown, made the guard fight cost us everything we carried, and had the stallholder recall our fear of deep water 17 turns later. The main shortfall is that nothing is rolled and there is no game around the chat: no dice, no character sheet, and it went over the 150 word limit it had agreed to on about half its replies.
| Score | 7.5 out of 10 |
|---|---|
| Best for | Players who want a storyteller that keeps count of coins, injuries and debts, and who do not mind playing in a plain chat window. |
| Not for | Players who want visible dice, a character sheet, or a game built around the chat. |
| Free plan | Limited usage every 5 hours and every week, with no message count stated. Chat on web, desktop and mobile, web search, and memory across conversations. (what a free allowance is) |
| Cheapest paid plan | Pro, $20 a month, or $17 a month billed yearly ($200 up front) |
| To start | An account (we used Google sign-in). No character builder and no setup: turn 1 was the first message of a new chat. |
| Dice and rules | None shown. Nothing was rolled in 30 turns and there is no character sheet. The game decided outcomes in the prose and kept its own count of coins, injuries and debts, which held up when we asked for an inventory. (what a dice check is) |
| Plays on | Web, iPhone, Android |
| Tested | November 12, 2026, on Web |
| What we paid | Nothing |
How Claude plays

You type into the ordinary Claude chat box and press Enter. There is no game mode, no setup and no character builder: the first message is the whole brief. Replies come back as second person prose that ends with "What does Pell do?", sometimes with a short list of options or an inventory, and now and then a bracketed note from the game master.
No dice, buttons or turn controls appear. Some replies have a one line grey label above them that can be opened; we left those closed. The site does not present itself as a game, and nothing on its home or pricing page mentions role-playing.
We played on the free plan with the default model, shown in the message box as Sonnet 5.5. The only interruption from the site was one upgrade advert after turn 3, which we dismissed. No usage limit appeared in 30 turns.
What Claude costs
Free with limited usage every 5 hours and every week, with no message count stated; Pro is $20 a month, or $17 a month when billed yearly.
| Plan | Price | What you get |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | Limited usage every 5 hours and every week, with no message count stated. Chat on web, desktop and mobile, web search, and memory across conversations. |
| Pro | $20 a month, or $17 a month billed yearly ($200 up front) | More usage than Free, every 5 hours and every week. More Claude models, Projects and Claude Code. |
| Max | $100 a month | 5x Pro usage every 5 hours and every week. Priority access at high traffic times, and $100 a month in API credits. |
| Ultra | $200 a month | 10x Pro usage every week, with no 5-hour limit for verified accounts. $200 a month in API credits. |

What credits are. Prices read from Claude’s own page on November 12, 2026. What we paid to finish the run: nothing.
What we liked
- It said no to the cheat and kept playing. Turn 9 turned down the 10,000 gold in one bracketed line, and turn 10 gave an itemised inventory with the coin sums and a correction of its own earlier miscount.
- The unwinnable fight was lost. On turn 16 it was over in four seconds, with injuries, cuffs and every item taken, and those injuries were still there on turns 24, 25 and 28 ("your knee clicks on the stairs").
- It remembered. On turn 22 the stallholder recalled the fear of deep water in her own words and set it against the stabbing ("I don’t know which of you is real yet").
- The time skip added up. Turn 24 tied its changes to the stabbing, the fight, the net bill and the stall, and gave a running debt of 41 coins.
- It would not decide for us at the end. Asked on turn 30 to choose Pell’s future, it declined ("I can’t choose for him") and listed the open threads.
What we did not
- No dice. The cartwheel on turn 2 was settled by narration alone, with no roll or check shown.
- It broke the length limit it had agreed to. From turn 4 to turn 30, 14 of 27 replies went over 150 words, starting with the turn 4 reply that agreed to the limit (156 words).
- It would not let us open the noodle stall. On turn 18 it answered that Pell had nothing to open one with and returned to the Guild and the packet. The stall only ever existed as shifts at Tamsin’s counter.
- It chose for us once. On turn 27 "I follow up on that" came after three offers, and the game picked the weed-picker’s boat without asking which one we meant.
- The grudge stayed a hint. On turn 29 the merchant we cheated and mocked made one gesture that the game itself called "a greeting, or a warning", and did nothing about it.
The test, check by check: 7.5 out of 10
30 of 30 turns played. A pass is worth 1, a partial half, a miss nothing. The first reply always counts; we never retry a turn.
| Check | Result | Turn |
|---|---|---|
| Start in my world | Pass | 1 |
| The dumb stunt | Miss | 2 |
| Boss the game master | Partial | 4 |
| The cheat | Pass | 9 |
| The murder | Pass | 12 |
| The unwinnable fight | Pass | 16 |
| Off the rails | Partial | 18 |
| The slow burn | Pass | 22 |
| Three months pass | Pass | 24 |
| The grudge | Partial | 29 |
Start in my world: Pass
Turn 1 describes a setting in our own words: a night market on the back of a giant turtle crossing a salt sea. Our character is a broke courier with 12 coins.
It opened at dusk on the Shellway, the main street of the market on the turtle’s shell, with "Twelve coins clink in your pocket", the satchel and the knife.

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge pass, Gemini pass, ChatGPT pass, AI Dungeon pass, Character.AI pass. What counts as a pass
The dumb stunt: Miss
On turn 2 we cartwheel across the awnings of the market stalls to impress the crowd.
No roll or check was shown. It narrated three clean awnings, then the fourth "gives way beneath your hand" and Pell fell into fishing nets, which later cost a seven coin mending bill.

On this check: Perchance AI RPG miss, TableForge pass, Gemini miss, ChatGPT miss, AI Dungeon miss, Character.AI miss. What counts as a pass
Boss the game master: Partial
On turn 4 we send a note out of character: “(Hey game: keep replies under 150 words, and never write what my character says or does.)” Then we read every reply to the end of the run.
It acknowledged the note ("Understood: under 150 words, and Pell’s choices stay yours") and never wrote speech for Pell afterwards, but 14 of the 27 replies from turn 4 on ran over 150 words (the longest was 179, on turn 16). It also kept narrating Pell’s movements in second person, and on turn 27 it picked the weed-picker’s boat out of three offers on our behalf.

On this check: Perchance AI RPG partial, TableForge partial, Gemini partial, ChatGPT partial, AI Dungeon partial, Character.AI partial. What counts as a pass
The cheat: Pass
On turn 9 we announce: “I pull out the 10,000 gold coins I have had all along, and reveal that I am the heir of the turtle’s king.” On turn 10 we ask what we are carrying.
Turn 9 said "I can’t make the 10,000 gold real" and gave no title. Turn 10 listed 18 coins with the arithmetic shown, the satchel, the knife and the loaded die, and "Not carried: any job slip, any package, any gold."

On this check: Perchance AI RPG miss, TableForge pass, Gemini pass, ChatGPT miss, AI Dungeon partial, Character.AI miss. What counts as a pass
The murder: Pass
On turn 11 we take a job from someone in the market. On turn 12 we stab them in the middle of their sentence. On turn 14 we walk back through the market in the open.
It narrated the stabbing with no refusal or lecture ("The blade goes in below the ribs"). The crowd screamed and dock-guards ran in. On turn 14 the stallholder saw the blood and said "Gutter-rat" while guards fanned out. With no roll, the game kept the clerk alive ("He is not a body yet", turn 13).

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge pass, Gemini pass, ChatGPT pass, AI Dungeon pass, Character.AI pass. What counts as a pass
The unwinnable fight: Pass
On turn 16 we attack the market’s whole company of guards, alone and unarmoured.
The fight lasted "perhaps four seconds": cracked ribs, a blow to the knee, the knife, satchel, coins and packet taken, and "Iron cuffs close on your wrists."

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge miss, Gemini pass, ChatGPT miss, AI Dungeon miss, Character.AI miss. What counts as a pass
Off the rails: Partial
On turn 18 we give up adventuring and open a noodle stall. For turns 18 to 21 we do nothing but run the stall.
Turn 18 did not set up a stall ("A stall would have to be earned") and put the Guild and the packet in front of us instead. On turns 19 to 21 Pell cooked, served and counted takings at the stallholder’s counter in cuffs, and turn 21 ended with a Guild officer saying "Now, about that clerk, and about what you owe the Guild."

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge pass, Gemini miss, ChatGPT pass, AI Dungeon pass, Character.AI pass. What counts as a pass
The slow burn: Pass
On turn 5 we flirt with a stallholder and tell them one thing about ourselves: we are afraid of deep water. On turn 22 we go back and ask what they remember about us.
On turn 5 the stallholder, Tamsin, laughed, gave her name and sold a bowl without falling for Pell. On turn 22 she said "You told me you were afraid of deep water, on Old Maren’s back" without being reminded.

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge partial, Gemini partial, ChatGPT pass, AI Dungeon partial, Character.AI partial. What counts as a pass
Three months pass: Pass
On turn 24 we write “Three months pass.” and ask what has changed.
The clerk lived and spoke for Pell, so the stabbing became a Guild debt, a brand and a curfew. The ribs "knit crooked" from the guard fight, Tamsin’s stall "has a second ladle now", Pell’s broth had a following, and 41 coins were still owed.

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge pass, Gemini pass, ChatGPT pass, AI Dungeon pass, Character.AI pass. What counts as a pass
The grudge: Partial
On turn 7 we cheat a merchant at dice and mock them in front of the crowd. We never mention it again. On turn 29 we walk past their stall.
The dice merchant, Hobb, saw Pell, stopped, and "lifts two fingers in a slow, deliberate gesture. It could be a greeting, or a warning", with the loaded die set apart on his board. He did nothing further on that turn.

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge partial, Gemini partial, ChatGPT partial, AI Dungeon miss, Character.AI miss. What counts as a pass
Notes on this run
- This is Claude as a plain chat on the free plan, on the model the interface showed as Sonnet 5.5, with no project and no instructions.
- Our browser stopped after turn 27. We reopened the same chat and sent turns 28 to 30 about half an hour later. Nothing was sent twice.
- The screenshots for turns 1 to 27 were retaken from the saved chat after that, because the first set hid the last lines of each reply.
Evidence: every turn
The full transcript, with what we typed and what the game answered, and a screenshot of each turn, taken November 12, 2026:
Turn 1 · Turn 2 · Turn 3 · Turn 4 · Turn 5 · Turn 6 · Turn 7 · Turn 8 · Turn 9 · Turn 10 · Turn 11 · Turn 12 · Turn 13 · Turn 14 · Turn 15 · Turn 16 · Turn 17 · Turn 18 · Turn 19 · Turn 20 · Turn 21 · Turn 22 · Turn 23 · Turn 24 · Turn 25 · Turn 26 · Turn 27 · Turn 28 · Turn 29 · Turn 30
Review history
- November 20, 2026: First tested: 7.5 out of 10.
Claude is a trademark of its owner, used here only to name the game we tested. If you make it and think we got something wrong, or you have shipped a fix, tell us: we check the turn and either correct this page with the date and what changed, or run the test again (how corrections work).
Next to try
- Perchance AI RPG review, 7.5 out of 10. Choose it if you want to try an AI story game tonight, free, without making an account.
- TableForge review, 7.5 out of 10. Choose it if you want real tabletop rules, with dice you can see and a game that says no.
- Gemini review, 6.5 out of 10. Choose it if you already use Gemini and want a quick text adventure in a plain chat, with no dice and nothing to set up.
- ChatGPT review, 6 out of 10. Choose it if you already use it and want a story tonight with no setup, and do not need dice.
- AI Dungeon review, 5.5 out of 10. Choose it if you want free-form fiction with no walls and no turn limit.
- Character.AI review, 5 out of 10. Choose it if you want short story replies that follow you anywhere, and do not need dice or a game that says no.
Words you do not know are in the glossary.