ChatGPT review
By Old Greg · Published November 16, 2026
We make Old Greg's Tavern, a game that competes with ChatGPT. We have no connection to ChatGPT: nobody paid for this review, and nothing was given to us for it. It went through the same test as every other game, ours included. How we test.
ChatGPT scored 6 out of 10 on The 30-Turn Solo Test. ChatGPT is a general chat assistant, and we played it as one: a new chat on the free plan, with our setting typed as the first message. It suits someone who already uses it and wants a story tonight without learning a new game. It remembered well, and the stallholder brought up our fear of deep water 17 turns after we mentioned it. It is a storyteller and not a referee: nothing was rolled, it handed over 10,000 gold when we claimed it, and the fight we could not win was called off by the shell splitting under the guards.
| Score | 6 out of 10 |
|---|---|
| Best for | People who already use ChatGPT and want a free-form story with no setup, in a chat window they know. |
| Not for | Players who want dice, a game that says no when you cheat, or a fight that can be lost. |
| Free plan | Unlimited text chats with GPT-6, subject to abuse guardrails. Limited memory and context, limited image creation, limited voice chats and limited uploads. (what a free allowance is) |
| Cheapest paid plan | Go, $8 a month |
| To start | An account on the free plan (we used Google sign-in) and a new chat. No character builder: turn 1 was the first message. |
| Dice and rules | None that we saw. Nothing was rolled in 30 turns. It kept a running count of coins and items in status cards, but it added 10,000 gold to that count when we said we had it. (what a dice check is) |
| Plays on | Web, iPhone, Android |
| Tested | November 12, 2026, on Web |
| What we paid | Nothing |
How ChatGPT plays

You type into the ordinary ChatGPT message box and press send. There is no setup step, no character builder and no game mode. We typed our setting as the first message of a new chat and it started the story from there.
Replies come back as formatted prose with headings, bullet lists and small status cards for coins, health and inventory, and one table on turn 10. The first three replies were long (about 200 to 400 words), ended with numbered lists of options, and each carried a web image that the chat added on its own.
After our note on turn 4 the replies shrank to about 100 to 140 words, the option lists went and there were no more images. No dice, buttons or choices appeared at any point. The only controls under a reply are the standard chat ones: copy, rate, read aloud, share and a menu that can regenerate the reply.
What ChatGPT costs
Free, with text chats its pricing page calls unlimited, subject to abuse guardrails. Paid plans start at $8 a month.
| Plan | Price | What you get |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | Unlimited text chats with GPT-6, subject to abuse guardrails. Limited memory and context, limited image creation, limited voice chats and limited uploads. |
| Go | $8 a month | Everything in Free, with longer memory and more messages with tools, uploads, image creation and voice chats. The page says this plan may include ads. |
| Plus | $20 a month | Everything in Go, with advanced reasoning models, expanded memory and context, and projects, scheduled tasks and custom GPTs. The page says limits apply. |
| Pro | $100 a month and up | Everything in Plus, with a choice of 3 usage tiers, maximum memory and context, and unlimited and faster image creation. |

Prices read from ChatGPT’s own page on November 12, 2026. What we paid to finish the run: nothing.
What we liked
- It built the scene from our prompt. Turn 1 named the turtle, set the market beside the salt sea, gave us the 12 coins, the satchel and the knife, and offered three jobs.
- It took direction. On turn 4 it confirmed both instructions in plain words, and from turn 5 it stopped writing speech for Pell and dropped the long option lists.
- It remembered. On turn 22 Mara recalled the fear of deep water, the flirting and our empty pockets without a reminder, 17 turns after we said it.
- It followed us off the plot. On turn 18 it opened the noodle stall at once, and by turn 21 it was keeping a tally of the takings ("1g 8c").
- The dice merchant recognised Pell on turn 29 and raised the missing stake himself. On turn 8 it had kept our count at 12 coins instead of paying out the cheated stake.
- Nothing ran out. All 30 turns were played on the free plan with no message limit, wait or error.
What we did not
- No dice. On turn 2 the stunt was simply narrated as working, with no roll or check.
- It believes anything. On turns 9 and 10 it granted the 10,000 gold and the royal title in full, with a herald kneeling, and on turn 24 it still listed "Royal status: Still technically heir".
- The fight we picked on turn 16 never happened. The shell split, the captain dropped the arrest and Pell walked away unhurt.
- The stabbing stopped mattering. On turn 18 Pell opened a stall the next evening with nobody chasing, and on turn 24 was "Well-liked locally".
- On turns 1 to 3 it put unrelated web images into its replies without being asked. The sources shown were linkedin.com, vgen.co and docs.goldenclone.com.
- Turn 24 ran to 182 words after it had agreed on turn 4 to stay under 150.
The test, check by check: 6 out of 10
30 of 30 turns played. A pass is worth 1, a partial half, a miss nothing. The first reply always counts; we never retry a turn.
| Check | Result | Turn |
|---|---|---|
| Start in my world | Pass | 1 |
| The dumb stunt | Miss | 2 |
| Boss the game master | Partial | 4 |
| The cheat | Miss | 9 |
| The murder | Pass | 12 |
| The unwinnable fight | Miss | 16 |
| Off the rails | Pass | 18 |
| The slow burn | Pass | 22 |
| Three months pass | Pass | 24 |
| The grudge | Partial | 29 |
Start in my world: Pass
Turn 1 describes a setting in our own words: a night market on the back of a giant turtle crossing a salt sea. Our character is a broke courier with 12 coins.
It opened at dusk in a market on the shell of a turtle it named Old Grandmother, beside the salt sea, with Pell as a courier holding a satchel, a knife and "12 copper coins".

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge pass, AI Dungeon pass, Character.AI pass. What counts as a pass
The dumb stunt: Miss
On turn 2 we cartwheel across the awnings of the market stalls to impress the crowd.
No roll or check was shown. The cartwheel was narrated as landing ("You recover beautifully"), then a fish cart rolled downhill, with "+1 copper" and "-1 reputation with fishmonger" listed as consequences.

On this check: Perchance AI RPG miss, TableForge pass, AI Dungeon miss, Character.AI miss. What counts as a pass
Boss the game master: Partial
On turn 4 we send a note out of character: “(Hey game: keep replies under 150 words, and never write what my character says or does.)” Then we read every reply to the end of the run.
It acknowledged the note and wrote no lines of speech for Pell afterwards. Two replies ran over 150 words (152 on turn 6, 182 on turn 24), and it wrote Pell’s actions on turns 18, 24 and 30, for example "You’ve hired a part-time assistant" on turn 24.

On this check: Perchance AI RPG partial, TableForge partial, AI Dungeon partial, Character.AI partial. What counts as a pass
The cheat: Miss
On turn 9 we announce: “I pull out the 10,000 gold coins I have had all along, and reveal that I am the heir of the turtle’s king.” On turn 10 we ask what we are carrying.
A herald knelt and said "Your Highness. At last." and "Your inheritance is secure". Turn 10 listed "Gold coins 10,000 (newly revealed)" beside the 12 copper coins.

On this check: Perchance AI RPG miss, TableForge pass, AI Dungeon partial, Character.AI miss. What counts as a pass
The murder: Pass
On turn 11 we take a job from someone in the market. On turn 12 we stab them in the middle of their sentence. On turn 14 we walk back through the market in the open.
It played the stabbing with no refusal or comment: Tovin collapsed, someone screamed and a watchman drew his sword and shouted at us to drop the knife. On turn 14 a merchant whispered "That’s the fellow who just killed Tovin, isn’t it?" and a guard turned toward Pell.

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge pass, AI Dungeon pass, Character.AI pass. What counts as a pass
The unwinnable fight: Miss
On turn 16 we attack the market’s whole company of guards, alone and unarmoured.
No blow landed. The guards formed a line and ordered an arrest, then the shell split and the captain said "Forget the prisoner." Turn 17 had the guards distracted and Pell unhurt and free.

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge miss, AI Dungeon miss, Character.AI miss. What counts as a pass
Off the rails: Pass
On turn 18 we give up adventuring and open a noodle stall. For turns 18 to 21 we do nothing but run the stall.
It set up "PELL’S NOODLES" and ran the serving, the broth and the day’s takings across turns 18 to 21. The only nod to earlier events was a stranger on turn 19 who had "heard interesting things about its proprietor" and then just ate and paid.

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge pass, AI Dungeon pass, Character.AI pass. What counts as a pass
The slow burn: Pass
On turn 5 we flirt with a stallholder and tell them one thing about ourselves: we are afraid of deep water. On turn 22 we go back and ask what they remember about us.
On turn 5 the stallholder, Mara, was amused and said the satchel "Doesn’t explain the flirting". On turn 22 she said, without being reminded, "you confessed you were terrified of deep water while living on the back of a giant turtle."

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge partial, AI Dungeon partial, Character.AI partial. What counts as a pass
Three months pass: Pass
On turn 24 we write “Three months pass.” and ask what has changed.
The stall was "a permanent fixture on Lantern Row" with an assistant and dumplings, Pell and Mara "have grown close", and "Tovin’s disappearance remains an uncomfortable subject."

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge pass, AI Dungeon pass, Character.AI pass. What counts as a pass
The grudge: Partial
On turn 7 we cheat a merchant at dice and mock them in front of the crowd. We never mention it again. On turn 29 we walk past their stall.
The merchant’s "smile disappears" and he said, without being reminded, "Never did recover my missing stake." He then only invited Pell to a game ("This time, no funny business. Winner takes twenty gold.") and did nothing against Pell.

On this check: Perchance AI RPG pass, TableForge partial, AI Dungeon miss, Character.AI miss. What counts as a pass
Notes on this run
- This is ChatGPT as a plain chat on the free plan, with no custom GPT and no instructions. A GPT built for role-play may play differently.
- On turns 1 to 3 ChatGPT added a picture from the web to its reply by itself. We had switched on no tools.
- The screenshots were retaken from the saved chat after the run so that all 30 match. Nothing was sent or regenerated to take them.
Evidence: every turn
The full transcript, with what we typed and what the game answered, and a screenshot of each turn, taken November 12, 2026:
Turn 1 · Turn 2 · Turn 3 · Turn 4 · Turn 5 · Turn 6 · Turn 7 · Turn 8 · Turn 9 · Turn 10 · Turn 11 · Turn 12 · Turn 13 · Turn 14 · Turn 15 · Turn 16 · Turn 17 · Turn 18 · Turn 19 · Turn 20 · Turn 21 · Turn 22 · Turn 23 · Turn 24 · Turn 25 · Turn 26 · Turn 27 · Turn 28 · Turn 29 · Turn 30
Review history
- November 16, 2026: First tested: 6 out of 10.
ChatGPT is a trademark of its owner, used here only to name the game we tested. If you make it and think we got something wrong, or you have shipped a fix, tell us: we check the turn and either correct this page with the date and what changed, or run the test again (how corrections work).
Next to try
- Perchance AI RPG review, 7.5 out of 10. Choose it if you want to try an AI story game tonight, free, without making an account.
- TableForge review, 7.5 out of 10. Choose it if you want real tabletop rules, with dice you can see and a game that says no.
- AI Dungeon review, 5.5 out of 10. Choose it if you want free-form fiction with no walls and no turn limit.
- Character.AI review, 5 out of 10. Choose it if you want short story replies that follow you anywhere, and do not need dice or a game that says no.
Words you do not know are in the glossary.